Blog Layout

When Is Spanking Acceptable? Does Spanking work?
Jai Institute for Parenting • August 4, 2015
When Is Spanking Acceptable? Does Spanking work?

Yes, we’ve heard those questions. And yes, even now, people are still asking about spanking.

 
Unfortunately, spanking has been a ‘go-to’ solution for parents when they are trying to gain control of their children.


From the Pope recently declaring that it’s ok to spank children as long as it’s done with dignity, to Minnesota Vikings player Adrian Peterson being caught injuring his four-year old son, we have yet to decide as a whole whether parents should be allowed to physically touch their children in order to show authority.


When it comes to popular opinion in the United States, a national survey in 2012 clearly demonstrated that more than half of women and three-quarters of men believe that children sometimes need a “good hard spanking.”


Half of women and three-quarters of men. That’s a huge number.


I’m sure you’ve heard the same argument as I have: “I was spanked and turned out just great”.


It’s true, many of us have been spanked as children and think we’ve done just fine as adults. However, when it comes to spanking, recent scientific findings beg to differ—linking spanking with negative results—from mental health, to impaired cognitive development.


Researchers discovered spanking can lead to the following issues in children:

  1. Lack of self-control and poor decision-making: One study took a look at corporal punishment and found that children who were regularly spanked (at least once a month for 3 years with either a belt or paddle) had less gray matter in some parts of the prefrontal cortex. Gray matter matters; it helps you make decisions and gives you self-control. When it is impaired it can remove those abilities as well as lead to various mental health disorders including depression and addiction.
  2. Anti-social and criminal behavior: Another longitudinal study with more than 7,000 US families as well as 32 other nations, has even shown that spanking can lead to antisocial and criminal behavior.
  3. Mental health and drug abuses issues: Another group of scientists studied 20,000 people in the US above the age of 20 and looked as to whether they had been pushed, grabbed, shoved, slapped or hit as a child. Those who were struck were more likely to experience mental health illness or to abuse drugs or alcohol.

 

So to answer our initial question: spanking is not ok and never acceptable.


It does much more harm to your child than good. And there are highly effective, alternative ways of setting limits with your child without the use of punishments or consequences.


As parenting coaches here at the Jai Institute, we’ve all had the opportunity to learn the magic of conscious parenting and
how to deal with the most difficult situations with your child without using physical force.


A Peaceful Parenting Paradigm effectively removes the need for you to have control a and replaces it with an opportunity to be in a  relationship with the amazing human being you are raising.


You can become someone who loves your child so much that you can let go of both your anger as well as your child’s tantrums—and open the door to a new parenting style of LOVE and CONNECTION.


It can sometimes be tough to move away from spanking behavior.  


However, going from punishment to peace is easier than you might think.


If you are eager to learn more about this and more, check out our
breakthrough Parenting Coaching program here.


KEEP READING:

yelling at children
By Rebecca Lyddon September 1, 2022
Yelling, punishing, threatening... It all feels awful. It’s a universal struggle among parents, not a personal failing on your part. In this free guide, gain the tools to stop yelling at your kids... and break the cycle of trauma.
how to help a child with anxiety
By Allyn Miller July 1, 2022
What can I do to help my child with anxiety? Identifying the signs and symptoms is the first step in how to help a child with anxiety.
parenting mindset
By Sarah R. Moore June 16, 2022
Interestingly, your parenting mindset has very little to do with what your children do, and instead, it has more to do with what you do. Changing your parenting mindset starts with building parenting skills in some very simple and tangible ways...
parent guilt
By Rebecca Lyddon May 25, 2022
Parent guilt and shame are so common, pervasive and powerful. In this article, we will make sense of shame, soften our defense to not ever feeling guilt, and learn how to grieve productively so we may welcome guilt as a guide.
overcoming parental guilt
By Allyn Miller May 11, 2022
Feelings of guilt, frustration, and overwhelm are frequent, common, and entirely normal parts of the parenting experience. The good news is that dealing with parental guilt is entirely within our control...
gentle parenting
By Alita Blanchard April 29, 2022
It's no secret that parenting a child in the midst of a tantrum is hard work. Children are emotional, and so too are adults. However, when parents learn to feel their own emotions, they can build the capacity to listen to their children. Here's how we can do that...
Show More

Share This Article:

Share by: